Earlier this year, we had fun looking back at the 1956 New York Times review of Elvis’ first movie Love Me Tender. To say the least, the reviewer didn’t like it. Do you think Elvis fared any better in the review published in Time Magazine? Of course not.
For some reason, the unnamed writer begins the review with a description of Elvis’ face. Considering that Pat Boone said Elvis looked like a Greek god, and Carl Perkins called Elvis the best looking man he had ever seen, it’s hard to figure out how Time could say these outrageous things:
“Is it a sausage? It is certainly smooth and damp-looking, but who ever heard of a 172-lb. sausage 6 ft. tall?” These were the opening lines of the review in America’s leading news magazine. It sounds like a fourteen-year old wrote them. Give me a break. They refer to Elvis as “it” and say he looks like a sausage.
“Is it a Walt Disney goldfish? It has the same sort of big,
soft, beautiful eyes and long, curly lashes, but who heard of
goldfish with sideburns?” These lines are just as stupid, but
at least there is praise for Elvis’ eyes and lashes. What
Disney goldfish was he referring to, anyway?
“Is it a corpse? The face just hangs there, limp and white
with its little drop-seat mouth.” OK, lets summarize: The
Time reviewer thinks Elvis’ Greek god face looks limp and
damp and white and just hangs there. I’d like to know what
this guy thinks a handsome face looks like.
Next, the reviewer describes Elvis’ body motions as he sings. “But suddenly the figure comes alive. The lips part, the eyes half-close, the clutched guitar begins to undulate back and forth in an uncomfortably suggestive manner. And wham! The midsection of the body jolts forward to bump and grind and beat out a low-down rhythm.” This is a fine description of Elvis’ live performances in 1956, but it in no way describes his motions in the movie Love Me Tender. There were only four songs, and two were ballads, and Elvis is very restrained doing them. I guess the writer just had to get in some well-crafted lines whether they fit in a movie review or not.
Then it was time to describe Elvis’ singing voice. “As the belly dance gets wilder, a peculiar sound emerges. A rusty foghorn? A voice? Or merely a noise produced, like the voice of the cricket, by the violent stridulation of the legs?” Now, I like a good simile as much as the next reader, but that’s the dumbest comparison I’ve ever seen. Can you visualize Elvis rubbing his legs together to produce a sound like a rusty foghorn? Awful. And the Editor left it in the piece.
The review continues: “Words occasionally can be made out like raisins in cornmeal mush. ‘Goan…git…luhhv…’ And then all at once everything stops, and a big, trembly tender half smile, half sneer smears across the CinemaScope screen. The message that millions of U.S. teenagers love to receive has just been delivered.” How about that. Despite the knock on his diction (going, get, love), Elvis does get a begrudging compliment. And we’ll have to give credit to the writer for a pretty good simile with the raisins in cornmeal thing.
At this point in the review, there were only four lines left, and neither the movie nor Elvis’ acting had been discussed yet. Here is all they printed: “In his first screen appearance, with a secondary role as the hero’s little brother, in an otherwise routine western, Elvis Presley all but steals the show from such better known players as Richard Egan and Debra Paget.” Finally, a full-fledged compliment. Then the reviewer predicted Love Me Tender would be a box-office bonanza. At least he got that right.
© 2007 Philip R Arnold All Rights Reserved www.elvisblog.net
-
The Last 50 Posts
- Elvis Mr. Potato Head Revisited February 26, 2021
- ElvisBlog Pictures on Pinterest February 22, 2021
- Elvis, Nixon, Clinton, and Limbaugh February 17, 2021
- 1,000 Posts February 10, 2021
- Let’s Have an Auction – Update February 2, 2021
- Negative Critiques of Elvis in 1956 January 29, 2021
- The End of ElvisBlog – Part 4 January 26, 2021
- Elvis, Marilyn, and Photoshop January 24, 2021
- Coffee Table Elvis Photography Books January 22, 2021
- Planet Elvis January 20, 2021
- Elvis Books – Part 2 January 18, 2021
- Songs About Elvis January 16, 2021
- Elvis Books – Part 1 January 14, 2021
- Thank you. Thank you very much January 12, 2021
- Eclectic and Cheap Elvis Reading Material January 10, 2021
- Elvis Birthday Cakes – A Pictorial Essay January 8, 2021
- Some Interesting Numbers For You January 7, 2021
- Opening Night – Vegas 1969 January 5, 2021
- Happy New Year, Elvis December 31, 2020
- Happy New Year with Elvis — 44 Years Ago December 30, 2020
- Speaking in Elvish December 26, 2020
- Merry Christmas December 25, 2020
- Five Fun Christmas Music Videos December 24, 2020
- Getting A Vaccine Shot – Elvis Style December 19, 2020
- What Elvis Would Look Like at 75 December 16, 2020
- Elvis Has Left the Building December 10, 2020
- Buy an Elvis Christmas Gift for Yourself December 4, 2020
- Tony Curtis, Elvis, and Ducktails November 29, 2020
- A Thanksgiving Prayer In The Times of Covid November 25, 2020
- Variations on the Iconic Jailhouse Rock Image November 21, 2020
- Col. Parker Masterminds the Elvis Summer Festival November 13, 2020
- A Closer Look at Elvis’ Gold Lamé Suit November 7, 2020
- Elvis Pics, Pics, and More Pics November 1, 2020
- Tickle Me October 24, 2020
- The Women Who Loved Elvis October 17, 2020
- 75 Reasons We (Still) Love Elvis October 9, 2020
- Another Assortment of Elvis Goodies That Need a New Home October 3, 2020
- The King Revealed September 26, 2020
- Amusing Captions for Elvis Photos September 23, 2020
- FBI Investigates the Strange Elvis Pimple Scam September 19, 2020
- I Can’t Believe It. An Elvis Photo I’ve Never Seen Before September 17, 2020
- A Nice Assortment of Elvis Goodies That Need a New Home September 12, 2020
- Elvis Photos in the American Cool Exhibition September 7, 2020
- The End of ElvisBlog — Part 2 September 5, 2020
- Auction Results and Backgrounds on Six Elvis Rings September 3, 2020
- Will Vandals Attack Elvis Statues Next September 2, 2020
- Elvis and Southern Maid Donuts August 29, 2020
- ElvisBlog Before There Were Pictures in Every Post August 22, 2020
- The BIG 50 Auction of Elvis Memorabilia August 19, 2020
- Elvis Movie Bloopers August 15, 2020
Subscribe to Blog via Email
My Favorite Elvis Links
- Elvis Today — Best blog for Elvis music. From Sweden by Thomas Melin
- Elvis-History-Blog — A detailed look at the history of Elvis by my friend Alan Hanson
- For Elvis Collectors Only Fascinating forums discussing everything Elvis
- Jerry Osborne Elvis collector, author, and expert
- Official Elvis Website Most popular Elvis website, operated by EPE
- Scotty Moore, Legendary Guitarist Detailed look at Scotty Moore and Elvis. Has features you won’t find elsewhere.
- The Mystery Train — Excellent Elvis blog by Troy Yeary